The best place to sell old or inherited jewelry is a buyer that shows you exactly how your price was calculated before you say yes. Pawn shops pay fastest but often offer around 40% of a piece’s gold value. Local jewelers vary widely and rarely itemize their offers. Online buyers like Unvault give you a free photo estimate in about 60 seconds, test your jewelry on video, and pay you 80–85% of the tested value after a 15–20% fee, with free insured shipping both ways.
If you have a jewelry box full of necklaces you never wear, rings that no longer fit, or earrings that lost their match, those pieces may be worth more than you think. Here’s how your selling options compare, and how to make sure you get a fair price wherever you sell.
Is your old jewelry worth selling?
Gold, silver, platinum, natural diamonds and designer pieces keep their value even when they’re broken, dated or no longer your style.
- Gold is still near historic highs. It traded around $4,000 an ounce in November 2026, roughly 14 times its average price in 2000 (about $279).
- Most households have more than they realize. Unvault’s 2026 Jewelry Drawer Index estimates U.S. homes hold about $750 billion in gold jewelry, or roughly $5,700 per household, counting gold content alone at mid-2026 prices.
- Older pieces have gained the most. A bracelet bought 25 years ago, when gold averaged under $300 an ounce, may now hold many times what you paid in metal value alone.
It’s worth finding out what you have, especially before passing pieces on or downsizing.
How to sell inherited jewelry

Inheriting jewelry is one of the most common reasons people sell, and it pays to go slowly. These five steps help you get a fair price without regrets.
1. Sort before you sell. Set aside pieces with sentimental value or that family members may want. Agree on who gets what before anything is sold.
2. Look for pieces worth more than their metal. Signed designer pieces, antiques and jewelry with natural diamonds can be worth more than their gold value. Keep any boxes, receipts or certificates.
3. Get every piece valued first. A free photo estimate shows what you have before you decide. With Unvault, you can value a whole collection with no obligation, sell only the pieces you choose, and get the rest back free.
4. Don’t rely on an old insurance appraisal. Appraisals list replacement value, which is usually far higher than what any buyer will pay.
5. Check on taxes for large sales. If you’re selling a significant amount, ask a tax professional whether you’ll owe anything on the gain.
Where is the best place to sell jewelry?
It depends on what matters most to you: speed, a face-to-face conversation, or the highest payout with a clear breakdown. Here’s how the four main options compare.
| Where to sell | What you’ll typically get | Do you see how the price was set? | Best for |
| Pawn Shop | Often around 40% of gold value (20-60% range) | Rarely | Cash the same day |
| Local Jeweler | Varies widely; some offer store credit only | Sometimes | An in-person conversation |
| Typical Mail-In Buyer | Varies; you ship before knowing the value | Varies | Selling from home |
| Unvault | 80-85% of the tested value after a 15-20% fee | Yes: itemized report & evaluation video | A free estimate first, then a transparent offer |
Pawn shops are fast, but they’re resale and lending businesses, so they build in a large margin. One industry study of pawn shop payouts found they average about 40% of gold’s melt value.
Local jewelers let you talk to someone in person. Offers vary a lot from store to store, and many won’t show you how they reached their number.
Mail-in buyers let you sell from home, but many require you to ship your jewelry before you know what it’s worth. Look for insured shipping, a clear testing process and the option to have your jewelry returned for free.
Online buyers with photo estimates, like Unvault, combine the convenience of mail-in selling with a free estimate before you send anything.
How does Unvault work?

Unvault is an AI-powered platform where you can snap a photo of your jewelry, get an instant valuation, and sell directly from home. Selling takes about 5 to 8 business days from shipping to payment.
1. Get a free estimate in about 60 seconds. Upload photos and answer a few questions, like metal type and karat stamp. There’s no obligation to sell.
2. Ship for free. If you want to sell, Unvault emails a prepaid FedEx label. Every package is insured up to its estimated value, and you can ask for extra coverage on higher-value pieces. Orders have a $200 minimum.
3. Watch your jewelry being tested. At Unvault’s New York processing facility, the team records the unboxing, then weighs and X-ray tests each piece on camera. You get the video.
4. Review an itemized offer. You’ll see the metal type, purity and weight of every piece, its tested value, and Unvault’s 15–20% fee, all before you decide.
5. Accept or get your jewelry back. You have five business days to respond. If you accept, you’re paid by bank transfer, PayPal or check. If you decline, Unvault ships your jewelry back free.
Is Unvault legit?
Unvault is accredited by the Better Business Bureau with an A- rating and holds a 4.9 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot. More than 100,000 people have used it to value their jewelry. Unvault has been featured in Bloomberg, Entrepreneur, JCK and CBS News.
What sets it apart is transparency. Instead of one lump-sum number, you get a video of your evaluation and a line-by-line breakdown, so you can check the math yourself before accepting.
What jewelry can you sell to Unvault?
Unvault buys gold, silver and platinum jewelry, including pieces that are broken, tangled or missing a match.
Unvault buys:
- Gold, silver and platinum rings, necklaces, bracelets and earrings
- Jewelry with natural diamonds or gemstones
- Designer, branded and estate jewelry
- Solid gold watches
- Broken chains, single earrings and damaged pieces
- Inherited jewelry and family heirlooms
Unvault doesn’t buy: gold-plated or gold-filled jewelry, loose stones, pearls or lab-grown diamonds.
How do you know what your jewelry is worth?
Wherever you sell, these four steps help you spot a lowball offer.
1. Check the karat stamp. Look for a tiny marking near the clasp or inside a ring. 10K is 41.7% pure gold, 14K is 58.3% and 18K is 75%. European stamps use numbers instead: 417, 585 and 750.
2. Work out the gold value. Multiply the weight in grams by the purity, then by the day’s gold price per gram. For example, a 10-gram 14K chain at about $129 per gram holds roughly $750 in gold (10 × 0.583 × $129).
3. Get an estimate before you ship anything. Never feel pressured to mail valuables without knowing roughly what they’re worth. A free photo estimate tells you whether a sale is worth pursuing.
4. Ask for an itemized offer. A reputable buyer should show the metal, purity, weight, any stones, and every fee. If they can’t explain their number, get a second opinion.
One more tip: a family heirloom, antique or signed designer piece can be worth more than its metal. Gather any receipts or certificates, and don’t rush a sentimental decision.
Frequently asked questions
How much does Unvault charge? Unvault charges a 15–20% platform fee on the tested value of your jewelry. Estimates, shipping and returns are free.
Do I have to sell after getting an estimate? No. The photo estimate is free with no obligation, and you can decline the final offer too.
Is it safe to mail jewelry to Unvault? Every package ships with a prepaid FedEx label and is insured up to its estimated value. You can request extra coverage for valuable pieces, and every item is tested on video.
What if I don’t like the final offer? Let Unvault know within five business days, and it will ship your jewelry back for free.
How long does it take to get paid? Most sellers finish in about 5 to 8 business days, depending on shipping and payment method.
Is there a minimum order? Yes, $200.
Turn forgotten jewelry into something useful
Whether you’ve inherited pieces you’ll never wear or you’re simply clearing out a drawer, the first step is the same: find out what you have. With free photo estimates, video-recorded evaluations and one clear fee, Unvault makes that step easy. Sell jewelry online for the best price with Unvault and get a free estimate in about 60 seconds.





