Since many PRiME readers are post-menopausal, this headline “why postmenopausal women can’t lose weight” has not come as a shocker to you. If your experience has been like most of us, you know first hand that losing weight and keeping it off at this stage in your life has become “mission impossible.” Sadly, by and large, all the advice out there on dieting and losing weight does not have our age group in mind.
Allow me to introduce you to someone who totally understands our postmenopausal bodies, Dr. Laura Lefkowitz.
Laura is an M.D. with honors in Obstetrics and Gynecology, Psychiatry, Internal Medicine, and Radiology. It wasn’t until she was pursuing training in radiation oncology and seeing firsthand the effects of weight on women’s health that she shifted her focus from treating disease in the traditional sense and refocused on treatment through nutrition. In preparation for her career shift, Laura attended Columbia University’s Institute for Integrative Nutrition, where she studied all the various dietary theories and complementary treatments to traditional medicine.
In other words, Dr. Laura is not just another dietician with a theory on how to lose weight. She is an expert. An expert on women our age and our bodies, and she knows why postmenopausal women can’t lose weight. As she explained in PRiME’s interview with her, she approaches nutritional needs for women by life spans or cycles. First is the birth to puberty growth stage, where the body is growing and needs more calories per body weight than in any other time in life. Next comes puberty through childbearing. The body is no longer in a growth stage and needs fewer calories, but the body still has fairly strong nutritional needs as the body is constantly preparing for a potential pregnancy.
Why postmenopausal women can’t lose weight
Then along comes that postmenopausal stage, whatever age that is. The body stops making estrogen, and the ovaries shut down since the body doesn’t need them after we stop making babies. However, as Dr. Laura explains, “Estrogen makes us feel good. It makes us pretty. It keeps our brain sharp and our skin nice. As a result, our bodies try to hang on to some of it.”
While our body can make a little estrogen in the adrenal glands, the other place we can provide it is in our peripheral fat stores. The body tries to preserve some of the estrogens by storing fat. Our insulin levels rise so we can put on weight, anywhere from five to 20 pounds. And while our blood vessels are happy, we aren’t so happy when we look in the mirror and see the extra pounds. Those extra pounds aren’t good for our hearts, either, and they are hard on our joints.
When our life expectancy was much shorter, those extra pounds weren’t as much of a problem, but now that we live longer and want to be active into our 70s and 80s, we have to change our diet. Our bodies don’t metabolize carbohydrates well anymore. We have an overactive response to them producing insulin and storing fat. That is why it’s hard to lose weight. We have to let go of things and adapt our behavior to our hormonal system.
Change the Way You Look at Food
So it’s not about dieting. Diets ultimately fail. You have to change your relationship with food. You now need to eat the foods your body can handle if you want to keep your weight in check.
That means not eating foods that increase insulin and eating vegetables and lean protein instead. Fruit should be consumed in moderation because of its high sugar content. Milk and milk products are a problem too. Our bodies don’t need it once we stop growing. Milk is a growth hormone. So drinking lattes and such is adding needless calories.
While Dr. Laura designs every eating regimen for the individual, she did offer some generalizations on what your diet would need to look like in order to lose weight postmenopausal. She recommends getting 50% of your calories from vegetables that are low in carbohydrates. Lean proteins should be roughly 25%. Healthy fats, like olive oil, avocado, etc. should make up 15%, and that leaves only 10% for everything else–other carbs such as fruit, whole grains, oatmeal, potatoes, milk in your coffee, birthday cake, and alcohol, which should only be 1% of that 10%. In other words, you can’t drink and lose weight.
Losing weight after menopause is different than before
Counting calories is a big waste of time.
It doesn’t work. A calorie is not a calorie. You need to eat a lot of low-calorie, high-nutrition food, which is vegetables.
When asked if yo-yo dieting slows the metabolism down, Dr. Laura said yes, but that it was not irreversible. However, we need to remember that the body is genetically wired to survive. The body doesn’t care if you look good in jeans. Losing weight scares it.
You cut your calories to 400 or 500, and your body thinks there’s an ice age out there where there’s no sunlight and thus no food available, and it had better conserve energy. It’s not going to expend energy making beautiful hair and nails. It’s going to focus on making blood cells and beating the heart, and breathing. Cutting calories that low once in a while is fine, but over and over again, the body says, “I don’t know when the next ice age is coming, so I had better start storing.”
Another reason why postmenopausal women can’t lose weight is our set point, and the body adapts to it. Whatever your highest weight point is, your body thinks that’s the best weight. Remember, it doesn’t know when the next ice age is coming. The hormones work against you to get back to the higher weight. For example, you weigh 125, and you gain weight – going up to 135. You diet, getting your weight back down to 125, but your body is saying, “Why are we down to 125? I liked 135.” And for the next year, genetics and hormones are going to fight you as they try to get back to that 135 weight. But Dr. Laura says it’s not hopeless.
If you can feed your body regularly with lots of vegetables and lean protein, you can calm down those hormones and get your metabolism working properly again. It won’t be what it once was due to age and loss of muscle mass, but it can be functioning properly. Extreme dieting also reduces muscle mass, making you burn less fat, so if you don’t work at building that muscle back, you won’t get your metabolism back.
While reading this, you may start to feel it’s all a bit hopeless unless you can afford a Dr. Laura to work with you on your diet and keep you accountable. It is for this reason Prime Women developed PLATE, in conjunction with another Ob/Gyn, Dr. Kathryn Waldrep, to help postmenopausal women lose weight. While many of the guidelines are the same as Dr. Laura suggests, we believe that portion control can allow you to enjoy almost all foods and wine in moderation.
The reason postmenopausal women can’t lose weight isn’t any one thing, but by changing the way we eat, exercising more, and being patient, we can maintain a healthy weight.